Rereading the “Shepherd Discourse”: Restoring the Integrity of John 9:39–10:21
Lewis, Karoline M.
New York: Lang, 2008 pp. xiii + 217. $69.95
Studies in Biblical Literature, 113
Description: The history of scholarship narrates a complicated past for the interpretation of the "Shepherd Discourse" in the Fourth Gospel. Both the internal and contextual integrity of John 9:39–10:21 have been compromised by a misapplied analogy dividing the passage into a parable and explanation structure, and by reading models that favor historical approaches. As a result, the images and figures encountered in the discourse have not been allowed their full imaginative impact and the tendency is to look outside the Gospel for their referents and explanations. The meaning of the "Shepherd Discourse" lies not in its relation to the rest of the Fourth Gospel, but to that which is imported into the narrative. Moreover, its function as the discourse to chapter 9, and in the whole of the Gospel, is overlooked. Lewis employs the strategy of rereading, borrowed from literary theory, to address the internal integrity of the discourse and the relationship of the discourse to the rest of the narrative. The literary phenomenon of rereading highlights the interconnectedness of the whole of the discourse and allows all of the imagery to be assessed at a figurative level. Rereading also foregrounds the function of John 9:39–10:21 as the discourse to the healing of the blind man in chapter nine, and calls attention to the importance of the "Shepherd Discourse" for the interpretation of the Fourth Gospel, especially the often-ignored image of Jesus as the door. This book suggests that rereading is necessitated by the Gospel itself as a fundamental feature of its unique theological expression.
Subjects: Bible, New Testament, Johannine Literature, John, Literature
Review by Beate Kowalski
Citation: Beate Kowalski, review of Karoline M. Lewis, Rereading the “Shepherd Discourse”: Restoring the Integrity of John 9:39–10:21, Review of Biblical Literature [http://www.bookreviews.org] (2009).
Adobe Acrobat Reader
All RBL reviews are published in PDF format. To view these reviews, you must have downloaded and installed the FREE version of Adobe Acrobat Reader. If you do not have the Reader or you have an older version of the Reader, you can download the most recent version now.